About us

Our Story

From 1898 to 1984, the Tompkin’s Building was the heart of downtown Middletown. Families came here to shop, gather, and celebrate under its grand staircase and clock. Today, it lives again as New Middletown — a tradition reborn for a new era.

Our Mission

We’re here to help our town flourish again by bringing timeless beauty, culture, and community back to Main Street. Our mission is simple: make shopping a joyful, memorable experience that feels close to home but as exciting as 5th Avenue.

What We Offer

Our collection is curated from around the world: jewelry, fine leather goods, silk scarves, and luxury keepsakes. We carry gourmet Italian pasta, truffle sauces, teas, Japanese cast iron pots, elegant porcelain tea sets, and precision German knives. You’ll also find Asian snacks, French natural bath and skincare products, organic baby care, wooden toys, and more. Each piece is chosen for its craftsmanship, beauty, and practicality.

Our Values

• Timeless Elegance: We believe in beauty that lasts.
• Craftsmanship: Every product is selected for its quality and purpose.
• Community: We host concerts and performances to bring people together.
• Care: We favor natural, organic, and sustainable products.

A Place to Belong

New Middletown is more than a store — it’s a gathering place. We host concerts, tastings, and performances that bring our community together. Every visit is both shopping and celebration. Join us, and be part of Middletown’s new chapter.